Whenever you are looking for ways to harness the power of the sun, multiple technologies come to the rescue. However, the dominating technologies are solar thermal panels vs photovoltaic. The ultimate goal of both technologies is to use sunlight to generate energy. Despite their similar goal, both operate on distinct features and principles. You need to understand the difference between both to operate properly. Let us explore which is more efficient: thermal solar panels or solar PV panels.
Overview Of Solar Energy
Solar energy is the natural yet most significant source of energy. It offers a clean, renewable and sustained power source. There are multiple solar systems, each with a different performance rate, features, and cost.
Types of Solar Systems:
Solar PV:
A solar photovoltaic system is a standard process that converts sunlight into electricity. This electricity is used for homes, businesses, and other off-grid applications.
Solar Thermal:
The solar thermal system converts sunlight into heat, which is utilised in water and space heating systems.
CSP (Concentrated Solar Power):
A concentrated solar system concentrates sunlight to generate electricity in large plants. This system is used for commercial purposes.
Benefits:
Solar systems are efficient sources of energy, making electricity generation easier for users. There are many benefits; let us discuss them first.
-
Solar energy is renewable and minimises carbon footprint.
-
It has low operating costs and encourages high energy independence.
-
It is a good initiative to increase the employment rate, including installation and maintenance.
Challenges:
Besides its benefits, there are some drawbacks to solar systems as well. You must consider them before selecting your desired technology.
-
It is strictly associated with sunlight.
-
The upfront cost is high, and it is a one-time investment.
-
Larger projects require a lot of space for the setup.
-
Energy storage needs solutions like batteries and generators that store energy for later use.
Applications:
Solar systems are used in a wide range of fields. They provide energy for residential, commercial, and off-grid electricity or heating systems.
What Are Thermal Solar Panels?
The thermal solar panel is a solar system similar to a photovoltaic solar system. It converts sunlight into a usable energy source. Besides that, the thermal panels differ from others in heat transfer fluid. It is used to transfer heat to air or water. Once the energy is applied to the substrate, it captures the energy and gets heated.
This system is entirely safe and emits no hazardous materials. That's why it is eco-friendly for residential and commercial heating systems. It eliminates the dependence on fossil fuels and minimises greenhouse gas emissions.
How Do Thermal Solar Panels Work?
Thermal solar panels are also of different types. All thermal systems come with heat transfer fluid, which is used to collect energy from the sun. Once the fluid is hot, it is used in the space to heat either water or space. It can also be used to generate steam for mechanical energy.
People at home often use Flat Plate collectors. These consist of a dark, flat surface encased in an insulated box. The collector panel is black, which attracts more heat energy and absorbs it.
There is another type of thermal system known as an Evacuated Tube collector. This panel contains a series of glass tubes with a vacuum. The vacuum eliminates the energy loss. Both of these panels work for the same purpose.
Another thermal system is a Radiant floor system, which circulates through pipes in the floor and radiates the heat from the liquid into the space, either a room or the whole house. Heating capacity depends upon the setup size of your thermal system.
The steam generated by the heat transfer fluid process could be used at a commercial level for energy production. Steam passing through a turbine powers the generator, ultimately resulting in the production of electricity.
Pros And Cons Of Thermal Solar Panels
Advantages
There are a number of advantages to using thermal solar panels, including:
-
This heating system provides the efficient conversion of sunlight into heat for your home or office.
-
This energy source is renewable, making it ideal for the environment.
-
Thermal heating systems may reduce your electricity and gas bills by a significant number.
Disadvantages
The disadvantages of thermal heating systems are:
-
A thermal system is not practically sound for whole-house electricity generation. A photovoltaic system is suitable in such conditions.
-
Radiant heating systems are only possible with construction processes. It is not possible to retrofit a home with radiant thermal heating.
-
As it only works with direct sunlight, it may decrease energy production in the winter season or at a specific time of day.
Highlight The Common Applications Of Thermal Solar Panels
Thermal solar panels are used for heating purposes, so let us explore the applications of it.
Water Heating
Thermal Solar panels generate hot water. A collector absorbs sunlight, and a storage tank heats the water with the stored energy.
Electricity Generation
Electricity generation is not directly possible with thermal solar panels. Thermal systems involve the same heating process and generate steam from hot water, which is later used to generate electricity.
Heating And Cooling System
Solar thermal energy can be used in industries to heat buildings and for cooling purposes. The collector uses sunlight to process space or air.
Solar thermal energy is a renewable source of energy that can help diversify energy production and encourage energy independence.
What Is Solar Photovoltaic Used For？
Solar photovoltaic technology is a sunlight-based energy source. It is a renewable process that converts sunlight into electricity. This process involves several solar panels according to the requirements. These panels contain photovoltaic cells that transfer photons into voltage, which converts the light into electricity.
How Does Solar Photovoltaic Work？
A photovoltaic solar panel consists of semiconductor materials. When sunlight hits the semiconductor silicon, it absorbs the energy from photons. After absorption, it releases electrons from their atomic bonds. This creates a continuous flow of electrons, which results in the formation of an electric current.
This current is initially direct current DC. An inverter converts DC to AC. Once converted, this current is used as electricity in household applications or the electrical grid.Popular Applications Of Solar Photovoltaic
Solar Photovoltaic (PV) systems are the direct source of electricity production. There are lots of applications based on Solar Photovoltaic panels, including:Electricity Generation
Solar PV systems generate electricity to power electrical devices, support the electric grid, or charge batteries for use.
There are some areas where the electricity grids are far away. These panels are used to light up the buildings.
Agricultural And Livestock
Solar PV systems are widely used in agriculture to power water pumps/irrigation systems. Moreover, they're a great source of light in farms and greenhouses. However, these solar systems need a power station to store their energy for later use. BLUETTI provides an AC180+PV200D solar power station, which is highly efficient in storing energy and makes the recharge process really quick. This power station is cost-effective and eco-friendly.
Communication Channeling
Solar PV systems are a great source of power for air and sea navigation, road signs, and repeaters. They provide the required power and ultimately make communication through channels possible.
Remote Health Care
Solar PV systems power remote healthcare facilities and refrigerate medical supplies. In medical centres, these photovoltaic systems help store medicines at their required temperature.
Key Differences Between Solar Thermal And Photovoltaic Cells
Although solar thermal and photovoltaic solar panels have the same functions, they have multiple differences. Let's discuss them to compare their attributes.
|
Components |
Solar Thermal |
Solar Photovoltaic |
|
Function |
It converts sunlight into heat for water or space heating purposes. |
Converts sunlight into electricity for various applications. |
|
Efficiency |
Higher efficiency (~70%) for heat conversion |
electricity generation efficiency 15–22% |
|
Applications |
Ideal for heating water, pools, and spaces. |
Versatile—powers appliances, lights, and even heating systems. |
|
Cost |
The lower upfront cost for heating systems but limited functionality. |
Higher initial cost (especially with battery storage) but more versatile and eligible for subsidies in many regions. |
|
Maintenance |
Simple, with minimal maintenance for heating-only systems. |
Requires periodic cleaning and possible inverter or battery maintenance. |
Q&A
Is Thermal Solar Panels better than Solar Photovoltaic?
Both solar panels are equally good sources of power generation. A thermal solar panel is best for a heating system based on air or water. A solar photovoltaic system is recommended and a highly efficient method for generating electricity. However, it is less efficient for energy conversion. These technologies have similar features for distinct circumstances. Thermal solar panels vs photovoltaic upfront cost is minimal in thermal systems.
Do Solar Thermal Panels Generate Electricity?
No, solar thermal panels cannot generate electricity. Their design is different, and they are highly suitable for applications like water, space heating, or commercial processes. Solar Photovoltaic panels are suitable for the generation of electricity.
Do Solar Thermal Panels Work in Winter?
Yes, they can work on the mechanism throughout the year. However, winter may affect the solar thermal vs photovoltaic efficiency of the process. The thermal heating process may take more time than usual. This is because in winter, sunlight is weak, and the time is short, which reduces the energy captured for the generation of heat. Moreover, to mitigate heat loss, a well-insulated system is required. To overcome the lower sunny days, you can choose a backup system or solar generator to store sunlight for low sunlight days.
Conclusion
Solar photovoltaic vs solar thermal panels both are renewable energy sources. Solar PV generates electricity by harnessing direct sunlight. Meanwhile, solar thermal systems are used for heating systems. Both have unique features for different environments. However, it's up to you which solar system you need according to your requirements.
A photovoltaic system is a versatile system that minimises electricity bills up to a significant level. Thermal systems can heat your home, office, or water. If you are interested in solar systems, either thermal or photovoltaic, both need a solar generator to run the process smoothly, even when no sunlight is available. BLUETTI provides the best solar generator, so you can get the results you desire for your solar system now.
